Love seafood, but don’t live anywhere near the sea? From wild Alaskan salmon to briny East Coast oysters, it’s now possible to buy all types of seafood online – typically getting much fresher results than what you’ll find at your local grocery store. In this post, we’ll take a look at some of the top suppliers across the US and what makes each one special.
#1) Maine Lobster Now
Best for: lobster lovers looking for overnight shipping
As the name suggests, Maine Lobster Now specializes in authentic Maine lobster. They work with fishermen on the Maine coast to supply a wide array of lobster products including live lobster, lobster tail, lobster rolls and more.
They don’t exclusively sell lobster though – you’ll also find a huge range of fresh fish and shellfish on their site. This includes add-ons and gourmet premade foods from delicious clam chowders to surf and turf combos.
#2) Wild Alaskan Company
Best for: supporters of sustainable, wild-caught fish
Wild Alaskan Company focuses on wild-caught seafood from the cold waters of Alaska. This includes fish like salmon, halibut, whitefish and several seasonal specialities. They don’t sell any farmed fish and highlight where and how all their fish were caught.
Their service is subscription-based allowing you to enjoy regular orders of North Pacific seafood that is flash-frozen and pre-portioned.
#3) Wulf’s Fish
Best for: discerning chefs searching for restaurant-quality seafood
Boston-based supplier Wulf’s Fish originally focused on selling to high-end restaurants, but have since set up a home delivery service. If you’re chasing chef-level quality, then this is your lane.
Expect pristine fillets and unique species of seafood. This includes premium octopus and squid and an extensive selection of caviar and roe. A standout feature of their site is their recipe section, which provides all kinds of detailed recipes for budding chefs.
#4) Sizzlefish
Best for: nutrition-focused customers and meal preppers
Sizzlefish focuses on seafood subscription boxes. Their products are precisely portioned and vacuum-sealed making them easy to grab from the freezer and cook quickly. Meal preppers will appreciate the option of being able to fine-tune orders depending on how much seafood you have per week. They also offer a lot of variety including staples like salmon, cod and shrimp.
This company is also health-focused, prioritizing clean simple ingredients, while highlighting the omega-3 content on products.
#5) Gulf Shrimp Company
Best for: fresh shrimp fanatics
Gulf Shrimp Company’s core product is unsurprisingly shrimp from the Gulf of Mexico. It’s all caught by US shrimpers and you can buy it in various forms from head-on to peeled and de-veined. Many consumers love shrimp from this region for its sweeter and richer taste.
Shrimp-heads aren’t the only seafood enthusiasts who will appreciate Gulf Shrimp Company – they also sell all kinds of other shellfish and fish caught in the gulf. They also sell prepared dishes and also a selection of sauces and seasonings.
#6) Honolulu Fish Company
Best for: home-made sushi enjoyers
For sashimi-grade Hawaiian fish, the Honolulu Fish Company is the best choice. They sell premium species like ahi tuna, ono, opah and mahi mahi that are all line-caught in the Pacific waters around Hawaii.
All their fish is carefully selected so that it’s safe for raw consumption, making it excellent for those that love preparing home-made sushi, crudo or poke bowls. Their award-winning packaging meanwhile helps to maintain freshness in transit.
#7) Crab Dynasty
Best for: consumers who are crazy for crab meat
Crab Dynasty is based in Maryland – a state famous for its crab cuisine including Maryland blue crab cakes. You can buy blue crabs steamed and seasoned, king crab legs and a variety of other crab-based products.
Crabs isn’t all this company does; you can also buy gulf shrimp, oyster and lobsters through their site. They also do party-ready seafood bundles and gift boxes. You’ll often find deals on their site worth snapping up, making them also a great company for those looking to save money on high quality seafood.
#8) Fulton Fish Market
Best for: shoppers wanting sheer variety of seafood
This historic NYC-based fish market has been selling fish since 1822. In recent years, they’ve started selling online. For sheer variety, they’re hard to beat – there’s an absolutely huge variety of products to browse through on their site.
You can shop for everyday fillets or go searching for rare, speciality species. Each order is packed by professional fishmongers at the market itself. The company also does subscription orders and also has a large range of recipes on their site that you can follow if you want to try your hand at preparing some new dishes.
#9) Secret Island Salmon
Best for: diners looking for premium salmon
If you’re looking for top quality salmon, Secret Island Salmon has you covered. All their salmon is raised in clean, cold waters (notably remote regions with strong environmental standards), and then flash-frozen to lock in flavor and texture.
They sell a range of fillets and seasoned ready-to-cook options. On their site, you’ll also find many useful salmon recipes.
#10) White Stone Oyster Company
Best for: oyster enthusiasts
The White Stone Oyster Company is a Virginia-based company that farms its own oysters. They’ve made a name for themselves for their deep-cupped varieties that have a distinctive salty-sweet profile.
They sell oysters to restaurants, events and homes across the country. If you’re planning a raw bar night, this company’s farm-direct oysters are certain to impress your guests.
Selecting the right seafood delivery for you
Each of these seafood delivery services has a different focus, so start by considering what type of seafood you enjoy. Then consider your budget – are you willing to splash out on premium seafood, or are you looking to save money? Services that offer subscriptions could be a good solution if you’re a regular seafood consumer. If you’re looking for fish or shellfish for a special occasion, look out for party bundles or deals. Make sure to also consider whether you want your fish to be farmed or freshly-caught – both have their advantages.
